Quick answer

A customer advance creates a liability until the related performance occurs. A completed credit sale creates a receivable; later collection reduces that receivable. Returns and discounts can reduce the amount recognized as revenue and the related customer balance. Sales tax charged to customers is a liability, not revenue.

Performance, invoicing, and collection may occur on different dates. Once the recognition decision is established, each entry records the change occurring on its own date. The examples assume recognition requirements are met; sales taxes are covered in the final section.

Common revenue recognition patterns

Cash first, performance later

Brightline Workshop agrees to provide three identical training sessions for $900. The customer pays the full amount on March 1. One session is delivered on March 20; the remaining two are scheduled for April.

On March 1, Cash increases by $900, but Brightline still owes all three sessions and has not earned revenue. The receipt therefore creates a $900 Customer Deposits liability.

Journal entryReceive the customer depositMarch 1, 2026
Receive the customer deposit, March 1, 2026
AccountDebitCredit
Cash900
900

On March 20, one of the three identical sessions has been delivered. One-third of the $900 deposit, or $300, is therefore released from the liability and recognized as Training Revenue.

Journal entryRecognize the delivered sessionMarch 20, 2026
Recognize the delivered session, March 20, 2026
AccountDebitCredit
Customer Deposits (liability)300
300

Brightline’s March effect

Brightline’s March effect
StatementAccountEffectTiming
Balance sheetCashIncreases by $900March 1
Balance sheetCustomer DepositsEnds at $600 for the two undelivered sessionsMarch 31
Income statementTraining RevenueReports $300 earnedMarch
EquityRetained earningsIncreases through the $300 of profit before expensesMarch
Balance sheet
AccountCash
EffectIncreases by $900
TimingMarch 1
Balance sheet
AccountCustomer Deposits
EffectEnds at $600 for the two undelivered sessions
TimingMarch 31
Income statement
AccountTraining Revenue
EffectReports $300 earned
TimingMarch
Equity
AccountRetained earnings
EffectIncreases through the $300 of profit before expenses
TimingMarch

A different contract may require a different allocation based on its terms.

Under a perpetual inventory system, which updates inventory with each sale, a goods sale also needs a cost-side entry: debit Cost of Goods Sold and credit Inventory for the cost assigned to the goods delivered. The inventory cost formula determines that amount; the customer entries record the selling-price side.

Recognition first, collection later

A retailer using a perpetual inventory system delivers goods for $1,000 on March 28 and allows the customer to pay later. Revenue is recognized when the goods are transferred under the stated facts; the unpaid amount is a receivable. Collection changes the form of the asset, not the amount of revenue.

Journal entryRecord the credit saleMarch 28, 2026
Record the credit sale, March 28, 2026
AccountDebitCredit
Accounts Receivable1,000
1,000
The customer owes $1,000 after receiving the goods. A separate inventory-cost entry records the cost of the goods delivered.
Journal entryCollect the receivableApril 15, 2026
Collect the receivable, April 15, 2026
AccountDebitCredit
Cash1,000
1,000
The April receipt does not create April revenue; it settles the March receivable.

Returns, refunds, discounts, and uncertain amounts

Revenue should reflect the amount the business expects to retain for goods and services actually transferred. A stated trade discount reduces the amount charged. A prompt-payment discount may reduce the amount collected when the customer qualifies. Expected returns and refunds mean the gross invoice is not automatically the final revenue amount.

Record a sales adjustment when the facts support it and keep the related customer balance consistent. Doubtful collection does not by itself prove that revenue was never earned. Collectibility and receivable measurement are related but separate questions.

How common adjustments change the sales analysis
AdjustmentEconomic effectAccounting focus
Trade discountThe stated selling price is reduced before the sale.Measure revenue and the customer balance from the discounted consideration rather than recording an artificial gross amount.
Prompt-payment discountThe amount retained can fall when the customer pays on time.Apply the governing revenue model to the expected or actual discount and keep revenue and the receivable consistent.
Return or refundConsideration for goods expected or accepted back is not kept as revenue.Account separately for the revenue reduction, any refund obligation, and any recoverable returned inventory as required.
Credit deterioration after a valid saleThe customer may not pay the recognized receivable in full.Assess a credit-loss allowance; do not automatically reverse revenue that was properly earned.

Record an unexpected return

A customer who bought $800 of goods on account returns $200 of them undamaged. Their inventory cost was $120, and expected resale proceeds after selling costs are at least $120. The retailer uses a perpetual inventory system and had not expected the return when it recorded the sale.

Journal entryReduce revenue and the customer balance
Reduce revenue and the customer balance
AccountDebitCredit
Sales Returns and Allowances200
200
Sales Returns and Allowances is a contra-revenue account, so net sales fall by $200 while gross sales remain visible.

The returned goods restore $120 to Inventory and reduce Cost of Goods Sold by the same amount. This reverses their earlier cost-side entry; it does not use the $200 selling price as inventory cost.

Journal entryReturn the goods to inventory
Return the goods to inventory
AccountDebitCredit
Inventory120
120

Sales taxes charged to customers

A GST/HST registrant charges tax at the rate determined by the type and place of supply; zero-rated supplies have a 0% rate and exempt supplies are not subject to GST/HST. Tax collected for the government is a liability, not revenue. Eligible GST/HST paid or payable on purchases used in commercial activities can be recovered through an input tax credit, subject to the claim conditions and supporting records. Separate provincial sales taxes follow their own rules; the GST/HST credit mechanism does not apply to PST.

Record a sale with HST

A registered Ontario retailer sells ordinary taxable goods for $1,000 on account, delivered in Ontario. The applicable HST rate is 13%.

Journal entryRecord the sale and HST payable
Record the sale and HST payable
AccountDebitCredit
Accounts Receivable1,130
1,000
130
Only $1,000 is revenue. The $130 enters the retailer’s GST/HST liability even before the customer pays; eligible input tax credits reduce the net remittance.